Friday, March 15, 2013

Chapter 56-59

Chapter 56

Should a hearing person be able to write about Deaf culture? When looking at this title, my automatic answer was yes. I am not a part of the Indian or Native American culture, but I still have to study it and have written papers about it. I think that anyone should be able to write about it, however they should make sure they have valid sources and things like that. On page 335 it explains that the Deaf culture feel as though sign language is the ONLY thing that they have and they do not want to be made subjects of studies done by hearing individuals. I feel like this is understandable. The chapter also explains that the culture wants more deaf people to become distinguished in writing in the English language, that way they can write, too. I think that this is a good idea. I think that it needs to be done carefully and the person that writes must be very informed and familiar with the culture, but someone does need to be writing. Materials that are able to be read will help hearing people be familiar with the Deaf culture. When people are more familiar, the Deaf culture will be understood more.
On page 336, it explains that the deaf people ask that whoever chooses to write to try and understand from a deaf person's perspective before they write. They ask that the person becomes involved in the Deaf culture first. I completely agree. I wouldn't want someone to write about something that is a part of me that they did not even try to understand.

Chapter 57

Alexander Graham Bell was a huge advocate in the oral movement. He promoted the teaching of speech to the deaf. Bell believed that being deaf was terrible. During this movement, oralists tried to make deaf people speak and they tried taking away their sign language. I am positive that this was absolutely humiliating and degrading to them. However, they failed. ASL is still alive and becoming more popular even today. The oralists realized that what they were doing was very wrong. Now, in schools like The Clarke School, students aren't allowed to sign in class, but they are free to sign outside of class as much as they want. I am happy to read on page 341 that deaf culture is thriving and awareness is growing. I think it is an awesome thing!

Chapter 58

Medically speaking, yes, deaf is a disability. It is a disability because the hearing that is designed in each person does not work properly like it should. However, people in the Deaf culture do not see themselves as handicapped. I think that that is the best way to be happy if a person is deaf. On page 343, it explains how deaf people use their other senses and do incredible things to help them cope and to be happy in this hearing world. SO, basically in some ways deafness is a disability and in some ways it isn't. It is very confusing, but that's just simply how it is. In life there is hardly ever just plain black and white reasoning. When dealing with deafness, there is a lot of gray areas and misunderstanding. However, society seems to be making a lot of headway in understanding the culture, which is an excellent thing!


Chapter 59

When reading the title of this chapter "The Deaf community has been compared to a "ghetto that is disintegrating." Do you agree?" I honestly was confused as to where the author was going to go with this. However, on page 351, it explains that the Deaf community is similiar to a ghetto and there are a few reasons why. It states that "it is hard for us to establish free, open, and comfortable communication with the hearing community." I understand this completely! I mean, there aren't enough interpreters to go around, and I am sure it would get tiring of having to be interpreted 24/7. It is nice that they can freely talk and express themselves in the Deaf community without having help. Deaf people like to be free and they like to associate with each other. I think the Deaf community will keep growing, and I think it should!

2 comments:

  1. In response to Chapter 58, I agree with you that deaf people shouldn’t consider themselves being handicapped or disabled. I think it is so sad that some people consider them to be damaged and defective. I agree with you that it is awesome how deaf people are able to use their other senses in incredible ways to help them in the hearing world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i was really confused with chapter 59 as well! it was a very abstract comparison and maybe i just didn't grasp it but either way i find it ignorant to even try to compare the two. i hope the community continues to flourish and eventually unites as one with the hearing community.

    ReplyDelete