Chapter 37
I think it is ridiculous that it was EVER acceptable to say "deaf and dumb." Originally it was socially acceptable to use these terms, but like on page 214 it says to think about the last time that you used the word 'dumb.' I use the word dumb for negative reasons only. It is not a negative thing to be deaf. Why would you add the word dumb to it? Another word that may be 'silent.' Yes, deaf people are quiet vocally, but "deaf people are not soundless creatures" (p 218). The book explains that a deaf person can like noisy music and fireworks, for example, just as much as a hearing person. I think that those examples really help to put it into perspective. This is very cliche, BUT the words a person says can hurt worse than anything. Chapter 37 does a very good job of explaining why society should not use certain words. It also explains that "Deaf" is what is preferred.Chapter 38
Is "Deaf" a noun or only an adjective. I have often wondered myself. It does get confusing sometimes. As it says on page 246, it is impossible to formulate set rules for this use of language. Words or phrases such as Deaf Community or deaf people are more accepted that 'the deaf." Also, I have always wondered if you are supposed to capitalize the 'D' in deaf all of the time or just certain times. Chapter 38 explains that it is optional. It all depends on what you are talking about. If you are talking about the culture or a person or an entire population of people. When talking about the culture, I think the capital D is always used.Chapter 39
The title of this chapter is "When I use the word "handicapped," my deaf friend gets angry. Why is that?" Well, probably because your friend does not see himself as handicapped. On page 249 it explains that "there are two basic ways to see deafness." You could see it as a physical disability or an ethnic difference. Those in the Deaf culture see deaf people as just having a rich language and history for their culture. However, when in only medical terms it is a disability.Chapter 40
"Labels have caused us an immeasurable amount of damage-- in terms of self-esteem, and pride." This statement is very true and it hit me hard. Labels like "deaf-and-dumb" or "deaf-mute" make those in the Deaf Culture sound like freaks. The people in this culture are just as normal as the people on the hearing side of the spectrum. In our society, labels sometimes do have to be used. Labels like hearing and deaf should be used only in the correct sense and very carefully.In closing, I think through chapters 37-40 it is safe to say that most people need to be educated on what is socially acceptable to the Deaf culture. Before I was in an ASL class, I had no idea that the Deaf culture even existed. I want to think that people are like that and they just simply do not know. After reading this book, though, and being in these classes I feel like it is our jobs to educate those around us who don't know.
In regards to Chapter 38, I am glad that you too find it confusing whether or not the word deaf can be used as an adjective and a noun. That always confuses me. I think it just depends on if you are talking about a person or a group/organization. I agree with you, I would capitalize the D when discussing Deaf Culture.
ReplyDelete